You’ve made it to the final interview stages. You’ve identified a standout candidate, the team is excited, and the finish line is in sight. But before you extend that all-important offer, there are a few red flags worth watching out for.
At Thrivve, we work with leadership teams across multiple industries to help them build high-performing, long-lasting teams. And we’ve seen first-hand that even at the final hurdle, things can still go wrong.
Why Final Stage Decisions Matter More Than You Think
It’s easy to assume the toughest parts of hiring are over once you’ve narrowed it down to one or two candidates. But here’s the thing: the final stages often carry the highest risk.
A strong hire can transform your team. The wrong one? Costly, disruptive, and frustrating—especially in leadership or commercially critical roles.
Our benchmark for a successful hire? Someone who stays and thrives for at least 24 months. That’s the time it takes to embed into the culture, drive meaningful results, and justify the investment. And through experience, we’ve identified a handful of red flags that often appear right before a poor hire is made.
5 Common Red Flags at the Offer Stage
If you spot any of these during final-stage conversations, it’s worth pausing to reflect before moving forward.
1. Overly Lengthy Negotiations
Negotiation is normal. Healthy, even. But when salary discussions start to feel like a tug-of-war, and the candidate seems more focused on squeezing the last penny than aligning with the role’s purpose and potential—it can be a warning sign.
If compensation is the main motivator, you risk losing them later to a higher bidder.
2. Delays in Decision-Making
Everyone needs time to make a life-changing decision. But if a candidate who was previously engaged and responsive suddenly goes quiet, delays for weeks, or can’t commit without vague explanations, it could be a sign of hesitation or competing priorities.
A polite but firm deadline (around a week) can help clarify intentions.
3. Unconvincing or Evasive References
Strong candidates usually have strong references—people eager to speak positively about their impact and character. If references feel lukewarm, overly polished, or avoidant, dig deeper.
Informal back-channel references (from mutual connections) often provide the clearest insight into how someone truly operates.
4. A Pattern of Short Tenures
Moving jobs regularly isn’t automatically a red flag—context is everything. But if a candidate has a pattern of short stints with little progression or impact, it’s worth questioning.
Were they pushed, or did they jump? Were they running from something or toward something better? A great candidate can explain the “why” behind every move clearly and credibly.
5. Misalignment with Your Company’s Stage or Culture
Someone who’s thrived in a large, structured organisation may struggle in a lean, fast-moving environment—and vice versa. What looks like “great experience” on paper might not translate well to your specific challenges.
Consider the environment your company is in right now: Are you scaling rapidly? Turning things around? Rebuilding culture? Make sure your final choice isn’t just impressive, but right for your reality.
How to Reduce the Risk of a Mis-Hire
Here are some simple but effective ways to get more confident in your final decision:
- Check references early and thoroughly – go beyond the names provided.
- Communicate timelines and expectations clearly during the offer process.
- Listen closely to how candidates explain past transitions—look for patterns, not just individual events.
- Match the candidate’s experience to your business stage, not just the job title.
- Assess cultural fit and personal motivation, not just skills and CV highlights.
Final Thoughts
The final stages of hiring aren’t just about tying a bow on the process—they’re often where your best judgment is needed most.
While no hire comes with guarantees, being alert to small red flags can save you from big regrets later. The goal isn’t to find the perfect candidate on paper—it’s to hire someone who will make a lasting impact, grow with your business, and stay the course.
And that starts with making the right decision now.
Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.